(De)influence me - which of these vanillas should i get?

I'm looking for a good everyday, cozy vanilla scent for the cold season.

1) Mod Vanilla: i have tested it once, thought the opening was too fruity but the dry down was really nice and inoffensive. I liked it but wasn't blown away. 2) Eilish No. 1: did not like the opening, but loooved the dry down! The sweetness wasn't too overpowering which surprised me. I only tried it once though but couldn't stop sniffing my arm. It reminded me a lot of VS Bare Vanilla but less of that "burnt" smell. 3) Gucci Gorgeous Orchid: this one was love at first sniff!! I was blown away, loved the fluffy, airy vanilla but the longevity was a let down 🥲 I got around 3 hrs which i think is not enough for that price point... 4) Sol de Janeiro 59: i had a sample of the body cream and I adored it. Hadn't had the chance to test the body mist yet so it would probably be a blind buy which is ok at that price point for me. 5) Zadig & Voltaire This is Her: this one i'm still debating if i like it or just find it okay. On me, it is a nice skin scent but something about it irks me and i think it might be the chestnut? There's something a little too musky in it but it smells more mature than the other sweet vanillas and i'd like to smell more grown up lol.

So, based on my thoughts, which one of these would you recommend? Orher recs are welcome, although they should be < 80 bucks. ❤️ (tried sweet tooth and thought it was too sweet, i already own & enjoy cloud and bare vanilla).