Why does my foundation look like that?

Hi all. 29 year old trying to figure out how to do makeup for my wedding next year here. I normally just wear eye makeup because I’m a sweaty person so I have next to zero face makeup skills. I know I don’t HAVE to wear it for my wedding but I want to figure it out! Because if I don’t, when I have just 1 alcoholic beverage and start dancing, my face turns into a tomato.

I’m wearing CeraCe AM Facial Moisturizing Lotion with spf 30, Elf Power Grip Primer, and Fenty Beauty Hydrating Longwear Foundation. I applied the foundation with a brush on one side and beauty blender on the side with the mole on my cheek. Idk if that made much of a difference but I think the beauty blender side applied a little bit better.

I just feel like it looks so unnatural? And it highlights all the little fuzzy hairs on my face and I have never been able to improve beyond this quality of an application. Any help or advice? I included my bare face for reference. The first two products are brand new and the foundation is a few years old so that might have something to do with it. Maybe I just need a new foundation? Any suggestions that are under $50?