places to get bulk cheap little gifts?

hi!! i’m working on a play that closes tomorrow and i was a last minute addition to the team so i’m very behind on getting closing night gifts for everyone. i’m wondering if anyone knows anywhere that i could get small little gifts in bulk (probably 20 items total, under $5 per) in the city tomorrow morning? i’m thinking five below but curious if anyone knows any trinket stores or anything like that that might have what i’m looking for!! examples of what other people are doing/have done: rubber ducks, undereye masks, bandanas, tea, pens, shot glasses, etc