Day 5: Who is/was an 'average' Magic player that divides fan opinions?

Day 4 winner (average player that's loved by Magic fans): Mr Heart & Hustle, Darrell Armstrong.

For Day 5, we're looking for an 'average' Magic player that divides fans.

As per previous days, the player with the most cumulative upvotes will be added to the grid (please only vote for one player in each comment).

Voting will remain open for 24 hours 🪄