Herrington Arms HC3652P or HC365 Compensator

Anyone here have experience with any, or both of these comps? Reviews are mixed — just looking for the comp that gets my red dot back on target fast with the least amount of muzzle rise and recoil. I have 15yrs shooting experience, but have never used one, so your experience with these is much appreciated!

Running: P365/ True Precision threaded barrel/ Wilson Combat XL frame/ Holosun 507k/ MCARBO Short stroke flat trigger/ MCARBO Trigger spring kit: (striker spring, striker block spring, sear spring)