For those who replayed Rdr2, was the 2nd playthrough as immersive and enjoyable?

I love Rdr2, it has everything I like in a video game. I have somewhere around 300 hours in it and 100% completion.

Recently I've been itching to play it again (but would have to buy it on steam), but I'm usually not the one to replay games. So, I'm wondering about your replaying expierences - was it as interesting as the first playthrough? The world itself, was it still immersive, even when you knew all the locations and random encounters?