I don't believe Abby Jimenez = Emily Henry

I was recommended Abby Jimenez after reading all the EH books and it's not hitting the same. I'm reading Part of Your World and don't get me wrong it's good, i'm invested, etc. but the book is not pulling me in the way EH does. It's taking me double the time to read it too so its just kind of dragging.

Did I pick the wrong AJ book?