Blue and orange shrine but i finished it???

I’ve done this shrine like 4 times, I’m not getting an orb, there’s no pin behind it, and I got the chest (unless there’s a second?) On the map, The shrine outlined blue and orange inside. I have no idea why this is happening I just want it to look consistent with my other map shrines so I stop coming back. When I leave the shrine after beating it, the blue and green rings are there signifying that I haven’t completed the stupid shrine.

It’s Tsutsu-um shrine near Outskirt Stable.

Please help this will kill me