Opinions on Needletail

Hi, I saw the recent post about Hollyleaf, it inspired me and a friend to make this one. As I saw on the Reddit, Needletail is hated or loved depending of the post, but I didn't really see as many organised arguments for or against her here

I personally don't like her but if you like or don't like Needletail, can you explain why please ?

I'll start :

First AVoS book, I was actually fine with her, she was annoying but she was young and had room to grow. But she didn't. Her love for Rain can make me understand that she wants to go with The Kin, but the trust her and her clanmateshave in it makes me doubt that. She becomes much more interesting when she's afraid of Darktail in Riverclan's camp, and her failed redemption by her death is really nice.

But then, we go to Starclan and see she hasn't changed at all, she still blame Rowanstar for their failure (which is much more of the overpopulation problem, with too many apprentices) by saying that he's weak.

Him being weak as never been demonstrated nor explained btw, that's more of the clan's excuse to not blame themselves, he's struggling to keep is clan together after The Great Battle and a boom in birth. He needed support more than anything.

Needletail had so much room to grow but the didn't, she never really tried but at the end. She also coerced Violetpaw to follow her many times but I won't get into that or I'll never finish this post lmao

So, yeah, I just want everyone's opinion on her in nice arguments, and have a proper discussion with y'all, Thanks a lot !