What’s better than Exuma?

We went on a 8 day vacation to Exuma and it was amazing. We are trying to plan our next vacation and for some reason my family wants to go somewhere new. Is there a place in the Bahamas that is as beautiful as Exuma? We are middle class family, se we don’t have thousands of dollars. We stayed at Hideaways in Exuma and rented a car and boat and explored. They want to do something similar, but in a different location. For the record I want to go back to Exuma. Thanks