Girls with insta, what do you think of guys who don't have social media?

I used to have social media - at the time facebook, as insta was only getting to be popular - and at that day's standard my account was kinda hot (though feel like standards today went long way up). Then at some point when I was into stable relationship I stopped posting anything on social media, my instagram is a void, and latest facebook post is more than 5 years old. I'm not in relationship anymore and just starting to learn what dating is like again.

And so the other day I met a girl. Felt like had really good chemistry. She was looking at me I caught her gaze went to talk to her and felt butterflies in like first time since pretty long a while (took a year long break from women after relationship broke apart). But didn't had much time to converse due to circumstances, we exchanged insta and went our ways. Now thing is my insta is a void just one dorky profile picture. Her insta is almost a supermodel - not in overly exposing way - feels just right mix of classy, sexy and intriguing. I kinda lost all confidence at this point. I don't know why though because my ex insta was also kinda hot and I never though anything of it. Do women care when guy has blank page on their insta? To me it suddenly feels like it does matter. Because it did made me more curious, had a small glimpse into hobbies and social life. And sometimes they say picture is worth a thousand words. And I hardly have any pictures. But also at same time I also kinda feel that I'm not even sure that I can match up to what I seen. I mean I know that insta is let's say improved version of one life but still what I've seen kinda broke my confidence. Though I guess if I had my own little improved version of my life on it then I probably would feel just fine.