Need Advice

so long story short, my roommates dog got ahold of my Chanel ballet flats while I was out and ate the bow off of one of them. I went to Chanel and they said because it’s not “normal wear and tear” they can’t do anything. But “they’re always in stock if I want to buy a new pair”. Surprise, surprise. Anyways I took them to multiple cobblers and none had the matching leather, so I agreed to replace both the beige bows with black leather. What I’m considering now is having him dye the entire shoe black so they look more like these (pic attached), but I’m not sure what would be best. If you were me what would you do? Wear the flats as is with the black bows even though people would know that there’s some sort of defect, or dye the whole thing black. Please help!