Bars for a first date in Logan Square?

Taking someone out in Logan Square on Saturday. We both agreed we'd be most comfortable with starting off just grabbing a drink. Big fan of the bar scene there, but most of the bars I've been to have been super crowded and loud. While that's not always a bad thing, I don't think it's ideal for a first date. Does anyone have any suggestions for a cozy bar near Logan that will almost certainly have space for 2 at 6pm on a Saturday? I've searched old threads in the sub but haven't come across too many spots in this area in particular. Thanks!

Edit: This is an incredible response. Thank you all very much for your suggestions.