which should i get: villa or pony?

i'm undecided between these two shades. looking at comparisons online, seems like pony is a bit more mauve while villa pulls more pink/peachy? i'm curious if villa might pull to orange on my lips or barely show up. what do you guys think? for reference, a few looks of my face lol! i'm a light 5 in the foundation or g9 in the skin tint, lean towards cool tones